The short version
- The attribution. France's foreign ministry and its Cyber Crisis Coordination Centre blamed Shahid Kaveh, an IRGC cyber unit, for the October attacks. Paris prosecutors opened a judicial investigation and are seeking international arrest warrants.
- The attack. Attackers reached internet-connected refrigeration controllers overnight on 11–12 October and changed defrost settings so temperatures rose, reaching 50C for about six hours in some stores. About 700 retail locations were targeted and at least 15 fires broke out.
- Who was hit. CERT-FR names Casino, Leclerc, Coopérative U, Metro, Carrefour and Intermarché, plus butcher shops, a slaughterhouse and cooperative food-processing plants. Intermarché reported losses of tens of millions of euros in a single day.
- A wider wave. A second wave in early November hit refrigeration systems in other European countries and three French blood-service sites. France has not attributed those attacks, and the FBI and CISA have warned about attacks on cold-chain systems.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 11-12 Oct | Attackers alter defrost settings on internet-connected refrigeration controllers at supermarkets and other retail sites across France, overnight. |
| 13 Oct | CyberbanNews, a propaganda outlet France links to Shahid Kaveh, publicises the refrigeration attacks. |
| Early Nov | A second wave of refrigeration attacks is reported in other European countries and at three sites used by France's national blood service. |
| 9 Nov | France's foreign ministry and the C4 attribution report blame Iran; Paris prosecutors open a judicial investigation and seek international arrest warrants. |
The attack and the attribution
According to the French report, attackers reached internet-connected refrigeration controllers overnight on 11–12 October and changed defrost settings so that temperatures rose. SecurityWeek reports temperatures reached 50C for about six hours, and stores discarded fresh and frozen goods. France's Cyber Crisis Coordination Centre (C4) puts the number of retail locations targeted at about 700; BleepingComputer had earlier reported an estimate of 250 to 350 supermarkets.
The C4 brings together ANSSI, the military cyber command and the DGSE and DGSI intelligence services. It linked the operation to Shahid Kaveh through infrastructure also used to reconnoitre Schneider Electric industrial systems, use of the FOFA search platform for internet-connected devices, traces of Farsi in the attacker infrastructure, and the publicising of the attacks on CyberbanNews on 13 October. US agencies have identified Shahid Kaveh as another name for CyberAv3ngers.
Who was affected
CERT-FR names Casino, Leclerc, Coopérative U, Metro, Carrefour and Intermarché among those affected, along with smaller butcher shops, a slaughterhouse and cooperative food-processing facilities. Intermarché reported losses of tens of millions of euros in a single day; French authorities put total food losses in the tens of millions of euros and counted at least 15 fires. Investigators also found attacks on Schneider Electric equipment at small hydroelectric installations during the same period, with what they described as moderate effects.
A second wave in early November went beyond France. BleepingComputer reports more than 115 stores in six European countries, while The Record says at least 11 countries were affected, including British meat suppliers, and SecurityWeek lists Sweden, Belgium, Luxembourg, Ireland and Estonia. Three sites used by France's national blood service had temperature and defrost settings altered, but the attempts were stopped before blood products were spoiled. France has attributed only the October attacks.
Response and the exposure behind it
France summoned Iran's ambassador and said it would pursue European Union sanctions. On 9 November the Paris prosecutor's office opened a judicial investigation into organised cybercrime, with the aggravating circumstance of serving a foreign power, and is seeking international arrest warrants for the head of Shahid Kaveh, two deputies and unidentified others, according to prosecutor Laure Beccuau. An annex to the C4 report names Hamid Reza Lashgarian, Mahdi Lashgarian and Reza Salarvand.
Iran had not publicly responded by Monday evening, and The Record notes that it routinely denies malicious cyber operations. Foreign minister Jean-Noël Barrot said: "This is an attack of unprecedented scale and aggressiveness." TechCrunch reports that researchers have warned the web-based controllers can be hacked remotely and that some affected Danfoss models no longer receive security fixes; the FBI and CISA have warned of ongoing attacks on industrial refrigeration and cold-chain monitoring systems.
What is not known yet
- Who carried out the November attacks on refrigeration systems elsewhere in Europe and on the French blood-service sites, which France has not attributed.
- How the attackers got into individual controllers: default credentials, an unpatched flaw or simply exposed management interfaces.
- Whether the intruders reached store or plant networks beyond the controllers, or took any data.
- The final cost of the October losses, beyond the tens of millions of euros cited so far.
- Which EU sanctions, if any, member states will agree to.
What to do
If you operate refrigeration or cold-chain controllers
- Inventory every refrigeration and cold-chain controller reachable from the internet, including at small sites such as butcheries and processing plants.
- Remove direct internet access from those controllers and allow remote management only over a restricted network.
- Check the manufacturer's advisory for fixes and identify models no longer receiving security updates, such as the Danfoss units TechCrunch reports; replace or isolate them.
- Alert on out-of-hours changes to temperature and defrost setpoints, not only on the resulting temperature alarm.
If you run industrial control or OT systems
- Read the FBI and CISA warning on attacks against refrigeration and cold-chain monitoring systems and check your own exposure against it.
- Review logs on internet-facing control equipment for scanning and unexpected configuration changes.
- Limit which staff accounts and maintenance contractors can change setpoints, and log those changes.
For everyone else
- Treat internet-reachable operational devices as an attack surface: a controller that can be reached from outside the organisation can be turned against the physical process it manages.
- Make sure physical alarms reach staff independently of the affected system, so an altered controller does not delay a response.
Update log
- First published.
Sources
- France Blames Iran for a Cyberattack That Heated Supermarket Refrigerators
- France blames Iran for mass-hacks targeting freezers in grocery stores and blood banks
- France blames Iran for fridge cyberattacks, says some caused fires
- France blames Iranian hackers for supermarket attacks that sparked fires
New incident reports by email
One email a week with the reports published since the last one.